THE CRANE POOL FORUM thecranepool.net (.com)


Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Official CPFPEIC Thread

seawolf17
Jul 29 2005 08:40 AM

Welcome to the (first annual?) CPF "Put 'Em In Cooperstown" Thread. Please vote on the following list of players... put reasons if you'd like, but just keep the players in the same order for easy tabulation. (Maybe this will work, maybe it won't. We'll see how it goes.)

Any player receiving 75% of the CPF vote will be enshrined in the CPFPEIC Mini-Hall Of Fame. Please vote on the active players if their careers ended THIS SEASON. Don't vote on the future, just vote on the now. Here's the list:

HOF ELIGIBLE BATTERS

Jim┬ Rice
Don┬ Mattingly
Steve┬ Garvey
Dave┬ Parker
Ted┬ Simmons
Alan┬ Trammell
Andre┬ Dawson
Dale┬ Murphy
Tony┬ Oliva
Lance┬ Parrish
Dave┬ Concepcion
Dick┬ Allen
Maury┬ Wills
Joe┬ Torre
Lou┬ Whitaker
Joe┬ Carter
Ron┬ Santo
Keith┬ Hernandez
Gil┬ Hodges

HOF ELIGIBLE PITCHERS

Lee┬ Smith
Jim┬ Kaat
Rich┬ Gossage
Jack┬ Morris
Bert┬ Blyleven
Tommy┬ John
Ron┬ Guidry
Bruce┬ Sutter

NOT YET ELIGIBLE HOF BATTERS

Barry┬ Bonds
Tony┬ Gwynn
Cal┬ Ripken
Alex┬ Rodriguez
Ken┬ Griffey
Roberto┬ Alomar
Sammy┬ Sosa
Rickey┬ Henderson
Ivan┬ Rodriguez
Frank┬ Thomas
Mark┬ McGwire
Mike┬ Piazza
Rafael┬ Palmeiro
Manny┬ Ramirez
Todd┬ Helton
Jeff┬ Bagwell
Larry┬ Walker
Bernie┬ Williams
Albert┬ Belle
Derek┬ Jeter
Edgar┬ Martinez
Craig┬ Biggio
Chipper┬ Jones
Gary┬ Sheffield
Juan┬ Gonzalez
Barry┬ Larkin
Nomar┬ Garciaparra
Jim┬ Thome
Andres┬ Galarraga
Ichiro┬ Suzuki
Omar┬ Vizquel
Jose┬ Canseco
Fred┬ McGriff
Benito┬ Santiago
Tim┬ Raines
Jeff┬ Kent

NOT YET ELIGIBLE HOF PITCHERS

Roger┬ Clemens
Randy┬ Johnson
Greg┬ Maddux
Pedro┬ Martinez
Tom┬ Glavine
Curt┬ Schilling
Mariano┬ Rivera
John┬ Smoltz
John┬ Franco
David┬ Cone
Mike┬ Mussina
Trevor┬ Hoffman
Kevin┬ Brown
John┬ Wetteland
Robb┬ Nen
Orel┬ Hershiser


edit: removed Vlad and Pujols (not yet eligible)

ABG
Jul 29 2005 09:00 AM

Torre as a manager or player or both?

Valadius
Jul 30 2005 05:02 PM

Rice
Parker
Dawson
Murphy
Wills
Hodges
Kaat
Gossage
Morris
Blyleven
Sutter
Bonds
Gwynn
Ripken
A. Rodriguez
Griffey
R. Alomar
Sosa
Henderson
I. Rodriguez
McGwire
Piazza
Palmeiro
Ramirez
Bagwell
Walker
E. Martinez
Biggio
Larkin
Raines
Kent
Clemens
R. Johnson
Maddux
P. Martinez
Glavine
Rivera
Smoltz
Hoffman