THE CRANE POOL FORUM thecranepool.net (.com)


Forum Home

Master Index of Archived Threads


Rosenthal: Preston Wilson to Nats for Zach Day, JJ Davis

Rotblatt
Jul 08 2005 03:02 PM

http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/news?slug=nationalstotradeforrocki&prov=tsn&type=lgns

huh. Terrible trade for the Nats. Wilson's hitting .224/.280/.411/.691 away from Coors Field this season, and has a hefty .726/.991 R/L split.

Of course, I also thought all their offseason moves were terrible, so I'm sure the Nats will somehow wind up with the best record in baseball after the signing . . .

MFS62
Jul 08 2005 03:13 PM

Is this significant enough to warrant its own thread, or should it be in the "Rico Brogna,etc." thread?

BTW - I agree with your assessment.

Later

metsmarathon
Jul 08 2005 03:13 PM

well, i guess its an upgrade over marlon byrd.. but damn, that's an expensive upgrade!

Johnny Dickshot
Jul 08 2005 04:08 PM

I won't miss losing to Zach Day, and perhaps, his sinker works at Coors. But it was very obvious this week the Nats need offensive help even worse than we do, if that's possible, so this appears to be more or less fair to me.

Let's not get ridiculously All-Purpose: It's news. If I found it first, I'd have given it its own thread.

seawolf17
Jul 08 2005 04:11 PM

I look forward to Mookie's son striking out in big spots against us later this season. Good trade for the Mets, bad trade for Zach Day.

Willets Point
Jul 08 2005 04:11 PM

I second that. The A-P thread sometimes make it hard to find commentary on a particular event when your scanning through threads.

Edgy DC
Jul 08 2005 04:14 PM

We had a formerly-starting/now-backup middle-infielder starting at first.

The Nats had a formerly-starting/now-backup middle-infielder starting at first and batting fourth.

MFS62
Jul 08 2005 04:21 PM

seawolf17 wrote:
I look forward to Mookie's son striking out in big spots against us later this season. Good trade for the Mets, bad trade for Zach Day.


Not too sure about that.
IIRC he had hit the Mets fairly well for power throughout his career, especially at Shea.

Later

Frayed Knot
Jul 08 2005 05:00 PM

I kinda like this deal from a Nats standpoint. They need hitting more than pitching and it's not like Day has even been there for them for over a month now. And, although I confess to knowing little about Davis, he is a former 1st round pick by Pittsburgh (1997 - 6th overall) but is almost 27 w/only pieces of 4 seasons in the majors. Sounds like he may have been a high prospect at one time, but not sure he is anymore.

Preston's certainly erratic and overpaid (tho they won't pay all of it anyway) but maybe he performs well enough and even likes it back on the east coast and hangs around past this year.

Bret Sabermetric
Jul 08 2005 05:56 PM

According to my Colorado-based brother, who's so down on the Rockies he makes me look like a fanatical Met fan in comparison, the Rockies need to adopt a policy of getting little-used pitchers in mid-season, even at prohibitive costs, because Coors just wears out pitchers' arms. Any tweaking of the park itself (raising fences, lengthening the field, adding foul territory, etc.) still leaves the altitude, which is an insurmountable obstacle to a stable pitching staff. So acquiring (every season!) pitchers who haven't thrown a lot of innings by mid-season is (according to him) the only sensible solution.

Of course, the Rockies pay as little attention to his ideas as the Mets do to mine, so this may just be a coincidence.

metsmarathon
Jul 08 2005 06:30 PM

i kinda liked the alternating home/road staves, myself, with each tailored to their specific tasks - namely, take a bunch of pitchers who seem to be effective at altitude, and keep em there. go on the road, and use your sea-level pitchers. and of course, mix things up come extended home or road trip.

would it work, prolly not. but itd sure be different.

Bret Sabermetric
Jul 08 2005 07:32 PM

Well, the Rox would need to keep a AAA staff at Colorado Springs, DL pitchers at the drop of a hat, maintain a 14-man pitching staff at all times, and it prolly still wouldnt work--but what has, for them?

Actually, it makes more sense to keep a AAA staff in western Kansas, which is as close as western Colorado but less altitude--no sense burning out your AAA staff's arm as as your MLB staff.

sharpie
Jul 08 2005 10:42 PM

Wilson is in the Rox lineup tonight. Hit a homer.

Frayed Knot
Jul 08 2005 10:51 PM

Apparently this deal is dead, or at least on the back burner for a while. Seems that they couldn't agree on the minor league/money aspects of the deal.

Nymr83
Jul 08 2005 11:46 PM

a little 1st grade math for the Nationals-

(Preston Wilson) - ( Coors Field) = below average player.